Learning how to make homemade vanilla extract is the easiest thing ever. It requires only 2 ingredients and will save you so much money!
About homemade vanilla extract
The price for quality pure vanilla extract has gotten outrageous. This is why I have started making my own. And believe it or not, it’s super easy and so much cheaper to make your own vanilla extract.
I like to make a large quantity of vanilla extract because I use it every day in my baking. Small bottles do not last me long and I found myself repurchasing vanilla every couple weeks. That can really add up in cost.
Another great thing about making vanilla at home is you can make double fold vanilla for the price of a store-bought bottle of single fold vanilla.
What is the difference between single and double-fold vanilla extract
- Single-fold vanilla extract is required to use 13 ounces of vanilla beans per gallon of alcohol. This is considered commercial grade vanilla extract. Nielson-Massey is an example of a quality commercial brand vanilla and it’s often my go-to when I must purchase extract.
- Double-fold vanilla extract is what professional bakers use. It uses 23 ounces of vanilla beans per gallon of alcohol. This rich vanilla flavor can’t be duplicated by doubling the amount of single-fold vanilla you use.
For what you’ll pay for a high-quality single-fold vanilla, you can make your own double-fold vanilla extract at home.
Do keep in mind the cost of vanilla beans will go up and down throughout the year but it is still cheaper to make your own extract.
How much does it cost to make your own homemade vanilla extract?
First, let’s consider the cost of a bottle of good-quality extract. An 8-ounce bottle of Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract will cost you approximately $39.94 on Amazon. And a 4-ounce bottle of the same vanilla extract will cost you about $24.94.
That’s a lot of money for a small bottle and the way I use vanilla, it won’t last me longer than 2 to 3 weeks. This is the main reason I began making my own.
Now, let’s break down the cost of the two ingredients needed to make homemade vanilla extract.
- Alcohol – I like to use vodka but you can actually use a variety of different alcohols. Look for the cheapest you can find at 80 proof. I was able to get a 750ml bottle for around $11.
- Vanilla Beans – I use Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Beans for a rich, dark and creamy with an overwhelming sweet, buttery aroma. It’s my favorite type of vanilla. Currently, you can get 20 beans for $67.90 from Amazon. I need this many beans because I’m making a large batch of vanilla extract and in the long run, it’s going to cost me less.
Now let’s add this up and compare:
- 750ml of vodka = $11
- 20 Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Beans = $67.90
- Total cost = $78.90
A 750ml bottle of homemade vanilla extract is equivalent to six 4-ounce bottles. If you purchased six 4-ounce bottles of Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract, it would cost you $149.64. You’re saving $70.74 by making it yourself!
The printable recipe card with full ingredient amounts and instructions can be found at the bottom of this post.
How to make homemade vanilla extract
Choose your alcohol. I like to use vodka because it’s the most versatile. If you choose to use brandy, bourbon, or rum, the vanilla will have a different flavor that may not be suitable for all recipes.
With the 750ml bottle, you can make the vanilla extract right in the same bottle. There’s no need to spend money on individual 4-ounce bottles unless you really want to. If the bottle contains a speed pourer, the little plastic piece in the neck of the bottle, gently pop it out using a butter knife.
Cut the vanilla beans in half then slice the beans down the center to split them open. If the beans are too dry to split, cut them into 1-inch pieces instead. Place all the beans in the bottle with the alcohol.
Replace the lid and store the bottle in a cool place out of direct sunlight for 2 months. Shake the bottle every couple of weeks. The longer you let the vanilla age the stronger the flavor will be.
How to store homemade vanilla extract?
Keep the vanilla extract out of direct sunlight. I tuck mine away in the pantry for safekeeping.
If you decide to transfer the vanilla extract to smaller jars, these amber-colored jars are great for protecting the vanilla extract from light.
You can use the extract as soon as 8 weeks but it will become more rich and flavorful with age. For optimal flavor, let the vanilla age for about 6 months. If you have the patience, wait 12 months before using it.